Let’s talk diversity in books. When I first wrote this post in 2017, diversity was a talking point across book communities in twitter and blogs. Now, it is still an important thing to talk about.
Why do we need diverse books?
Simply put, our world is diverse and we need to see the reflection of our world in the media that we consume-whether it is TV shows or the books that we devour. It distorts our view when the picture a book paints leaves out communities.
We connect with the characters from the books we read, because we see pieces of ourselves in them. This is why diversity is important, because everyone should be able to feel that they are represented by their beloved characters.
How should we deal with diversity?
I’m Indian and while I did grow up on Indian television, the books I consumed did not have Indian characters for the most part. It is understandable that the Historical Romances I was living in as a teen did not have Indian characters. What is irking, however, is that some of these books do have Indian characters. They just happen to be stereotypical caricatures that exist to please a saheb or a sahiba. I’m not going to name throw, but still- is it too much to ask that characters from other cultures and races be given their due diligence while writing?
There are historical romances set in British Colonial India that come off to me as insensitive and tone deaf that I wonder that they were published. This period and setting is something I know to avoid because I have been burned so many times. This is apparently a shared opinion among many of my Indian friends, who all avoid historical romances set in India like the plague. Why? Why do these authors not realize that they offend a share of their readers? Do they simply not care?
That brings me to the point-how do we do diversity? I believe that diversity is representative of the real world. What you see in the real world, you should see it represented in the books. The problem is not that every book does not have diverse characters, it is that some books go to lengths to avoid having diverse characters.
For example, if a book is set in contemporary US/Canada, I expect to the country’s demographic represented there. In a book set in my country, India, I don’t except to see people of other races (In fact, it would be odd if they got shoehorned in). But Indians are diverse in culture and language and religion and the book should represent whatever place it is set in. But whatever you do, you need to be respectful of the people you are adding to your book. That is, please don’t write a character who is a caricature of the community.
But hey, diversity is larger than race and culture
Autism, physical disability, ugly people, pretty people, mental illness-these are all things that exist and it has been refreshing to see that they are being explored by authors now. I’m seeing lots of characters with disability in romance and fantasy and it looks like they’re here to stay.
As I update this post now in 2024,I can see that the scene has changed so much in less than a decade. We have more diversity than we did back then and it is so cool.
What do you think of diversity in books? Do you read books that lack diversity or is it a deal breaker for you?